Business lessons for Samsung, Nokia, HTC & Blackberry from Apple


After the sad demise of Steve Jobs, there were lots of apprehensions regarding the future of Apple, but with the recent launch of iPhone 5S and 5Cs, Apple is back to what it does the best – “Hitting home runs”.

Everyone talks about the Jobs era when Apple literally became a synonym of Innovation, but the most surprising fact I came across from one of the articles on was that “Apple’s R&D expense as a ratio of gross profit is only 10%, compared to 12% for HP, 15% for Oracle, 17% for Microsoft, and 21% for Google.”

It’s not only about innovative concepts and huge investments in developing them but some logical and intelligent business decisions taken by them and more importantly over the years sticking by them. I had been closely monitoring and analyzing Apple and their – intentional, planned or even unintentional –  strategic product launches and their marketing strategies.

Here are some of my key observations on “What else Apple has done besides innovation to be what it is today?”

1. Leverage the insights from your competitors’ plans as well as successes

Leverage insightsInnovation is not an acquired skill, it’s a talent. It’s OK to acknowledge Apple for being innovative, but Apple itself hasn’t actually introduced everything new, there were several features already introduced by Android specially that Apple took its inspiration from and introduced them with its own adaptation. And as expected they have become a rage since the launch of iPhone 5S.

What Apple did best was, specially with already available features from Android, to acquire the idea intelligently and integrate it in the next launch e.g. control centre, Safari or Air Drop additions in iOS7. For details, please refer to this interesting article by Sharon Vakni, CNET.

Don’t integrate and introduce anything to counter your competition – do it because it’s gonna be the next leap in your product functionality even if its someone else’s concept but it’s a proven success and majority of users are already preferring it .

Gather insights from performance of initiatives by your competitors and launch your product before your competitor does. Samsung is the best example…there was a recent story that Apple is looking into futuristic iPhone with wrap-around display and seamless glass housing. Samsung rushed and launched Galaxy Round, a smartphone similar to the Galaxy Note 3 but with a curve in the middle. it claims that this is the first device on the market to curve a “super flexible AMOLED” display. Other noticeable example has been the latest craze of gold phones after the recent introduction of  iPhone 5S Gold. Samsung launched a direct imitation in Gold and HTC One just did it too. And last but not the least the Smart Watch mad rush.

2. Technology has to be an extension of human behavior…a facilitator

Human technologyWhen iPhone was launched in mid 2007, Blackberry and Nokia were undisputed leaders in their segments. Nokia was reigning the consumer market and Blackberry was the default choice for business users.

iPhone with its high premium value was categorized as a phone for the early adopters and that too from affluent class despite its path breaking unique smartphone positioning. Although, from the usage perspective, it was a perfectly designed product that was catering to the needs of enterprise as well as generic consumers – with its email, instant messaging, games, apps and web browsing features – still it was perceived as a product innovation and not with this positioning.

As rightly termed, it wasn’t a phone it was “The Mac in a phone”. Apple literally extended the user experience on a Mac to a handheld device…as rightly said in the recent bio-epic “Jobs” (not verbatim), “Technology should be in the form of an extension of the human behavior rather than the other way around”. In all its products, Apple has always designed its innovative products taking cues from the user behavior as well as around the needs of the user, not the demands of the technology.

Since its first launch till the recently introduced 5s and 5C, features and treatment, every single feature be it iTunes, camera, messaging, apps, security etc. have been continuously added and improved in line with the user behavior. It won’t an exaggeration to say that to understand how a consumer uses and what TG prefers for music or messaging or photography, just refer to iPhone features for the insight.

Interestingly, Apple has a better score when it comes to integrating features or choosing the best features from the competition that are closest to user behavior…Samsung definitely comes on the second position followed by HTC and Nokia.

3. Differentiate between wow features and “The Big Idea”

Big IdeaWhat most or say every other mobile company lacks today is the guts to come with something totally out of box. Why every single phone has to look like what we have already seen? None of them have literally taken one step back from the mad rush, think totally new and come up a new utility based model…instead of just small additions in features or functionalities, blatantly replicated from Apple.

With every new handset launch across the world, lot of cool features are being added… HTC, LG, Lenovo and Sony etc. are only augmenting their new models with available features. Where is the new product…a disruptive product…a unique concept…we have seen that these features have a limited shelf value, consumers start using them, get bored and look for something new.

Every company is not Samsung that they can invest lot of money and flood the market with a different model with every $100 price increase. Blackberry was the first one to face the brunt. Nokia no doubt is has been on a revival path with its Lumia range – the biggest differentiating factor being its different as an overall package. Similar is the case with Sony Xperia, with its new and bold design it has been able to make a mark in spite of being any other android phone.

How long will these companies survive by introducing new models every quarter that are nothing but with some new features. They have to realize that – “Long term shelf value is for a “Big Idea” in hardware design or in the OS and not in wow features…” From the OS perspective, success of Android and dominance of Blackberry for almost a decade prove this.

4. Get a poster boy

01SteveJobsApple at one time or rather even today is known for Steve Jobs but Tim Cook has risen above his stature and with every passing day is strengthening a position for himself as a brand.

It is not about the entrepreneur face always…for every Mark Zuckerberg there is a Marissa Mayer…for every Larry Page there is a Eric Schmidt and for every Bill Gates there is a Steve Ballmer. There are numerous examples across industries where the successors of popular entrepreneurs have created their own mark.

These examples are clearly missing in the mobile handset manufacturing sector. Who are the faces for  Samsung, Blackberry or Nokia, how popular are they…do they have a leader who is their “Brand Poster Boy” for its consumers with whom they can connect or co-relate.

5. And last but not the least, create a premium aspirational value

stay_hungry_stay_foolish_stickerThere is no denying the fact that Samsung is way ahead of Apple in terms of features, but Apple has selectively chosen the best ones in its phones and has been successful in creating a premium positioning not only with its iOS7 or wow features…but with its state of art hardware. I was impressed to know from their website that:

  • It compressed first-of-their-kind technologies inside a space that’s a mere 7.6 millimeters thin and 112 grams light
  • The A7 chip is designed around 64-bit architecture — a first for any smartphone. And Apple did it because they wanted to put desktop-class processing power in the palm of people’s hands. And it supports OpenGL ES 3.0, enabling visual effects previously possible only on computers and gaming consoles.
  • (And this being my favorite) Take the glass inlays on the back of iPhone 5. During manufacturing, each aluminum housing is photographed by two high-powered 29MP cameras. A machine then examines the images and compares them against 725 unique inlays to find the most precise match for every single iPhone. A crystalline diamond cuts this bevelled edge.

Which other mobile company actually literally creates its hardware with this finesse? Every second model available in the market today is at least 85% pure plastic, exception being some models from HTC.

It’s interesting to note that Apple as well as all other companies are targeting the same consumers who can afford expensive phones. The only difference is in their communication and positioning – Apple has positioned its iPhone as a premium product which the consumers crave to have and eventually end up spending more to buy it. On the other hand, all other mobile companies are positioning their models as a phone that you can afford – no premium or aspirational value attached. Their entire communication/positioning being it’s for gaming, it’s for photography, it’s for business users…

When was the last time we saw an ad or communication stating this iPhone model is for photography or gamers…they just say it’s not a phone…it’s an iPhone. And it’s for everyone…period! 


11 thoughts on “Business lessons for Samsung, Nokia, HTC & Blackberry from Apple

  1. Nishith, this is great stuf. i love the nuances tat you’ve captured – the big idea, tat there shud be, if i may call it, “human technology” and the disruptive beauty of the big idea! Thanks for a great read.
    an apple-blooded fan


  2. excellent article. you have captured all the angles that most people today forget to look at. i wish more people saw it like this, or at least similarly.
    keep up the good work! Cheers


    • Hi Lalinda, Thanks for your appreciation and a thorough reading of my blog. Look forward to your viewpoint on some of my observations, what else you think Apple has done from a cutting edge effective business strategy perspective… Regards, Nishith


  3. Interesting and very vivid analysis Nishith. Question is whether it is doing enough to sustain the Samsung onslaught..or is there another game plan up their sleeve !! That will be seen in days to come. Good Write-up!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s